Casey's General Stores (CASY) has wrapped up FY 2026 with fourth quarter revenue of US$4.6 billion and basic EPS of US$4.40, contributing to trailing twelve month revenue of US$17.6 billion and EPS of US$19.28 as earnings grew 30.7% over the past year. Over recent quarters the company has seen revenue move from US$4.0 billion and EPS of US$2.65 in Q4 FY 2025 to US$4.6 billion and EPS of US$4.40 in Q4 FY 2026, with trailing twelve month EPS rising from US$14.72 to US$19.28 over the same period. This sets up a picture of expanding profit per share on a larger sales base. With net profit margin at 4.1% over the last twelve months versus 3.4% a year earlier, investors will focus on how durable this margin profile looks against future growth expectations.

See our full analysis for Casey's General Stores.

With the headline numbers established, the next step is to see how these results line up against the prevailing narratives about Casey's General Stores, highlighting where the story holds up and where the data pushes back.

TTM net income reaches US$714 million

• Over the last twelve months, Casey's General Stores generated net income of US$714.4 million on revenue of US$17.6b, implying a net profit margin of 4.1% versus 3.4% a year earlier.
• Consensus narrative points to store expansion and higher margin prepared foods as key drivers, and the recent numbers give some backing to that view:
  • Same store sales growth on a trailing basis is 1.4%, alongside trailing EPS of US$19.28. This lines up with the idea that growth is coming from a mix of modest underlying sales gains and better profitability per dollar of sales.
  • Forecasts in the provided data call for earnings growth of about 8.8% per year and revenue growth of about 7.8% per year. This sits between the strong 30.7% trailing earnings growth and more cautious views, so the current margin profile is an important reference point for whether that balanced case holds up.

Bulls argue that Casey's earnings power can keep building from here as higher margin categories scale and efficiency projects mature, and the trailing US$714.4 million of net income with a 4.1% margin is a concrete starting point for that story.

🐂 Casey's General Stores Bull Case

Premium P/E of 41.5x tests the bullish case

• The shares trade on a trailing P/E of 41.5x, compared with 26.3x for peers and 18.6x for the wider US Consumer Retailing industry, while the current share price of US$801.35 sits above the DCF fair value of US$689.95.
• Bears focus on this valuation gap as a key risk, and the numbers give them some clear talking points:
  • The 41.5x P/E multiple is very high compared with the industry and peers, so even with trailing earnings growth of 30.7%, the stock is already pricing in stronger growth and resilience than the broader group.
  • The DCF fair value of US$689.95 is below the current share price of US$801.35, which fits with the cautious view that expectations embedded in the price are ahead of the cash flow profile laid out in the provided data.

Skeptics warn that with the shares already at a 41.5x P/E and above the DCF fair value, any stumble against the forecast ~8.8% earnings growth track could matter more than usual for Casey's General Stores.

🐻 Casey's General Stores Bear Case

Quarterly EPS swings around a strong TTM trend

• Across FY 2026, quarterly basic EPS moved between US$3.51 and US$5.80, yet trailing twelve month EPS still climbed to US$19.28 from US$14.72, in line with the 30.7% earnings growth cited in the analysis.
• Analysts' consensus view links this kind of pattern to a business that mixes steady core demand with periods of heavier investment and acquisition integration:
  • Within the year, EPS ranged from US$3.51 in Q3 FY 2026 to US$5.80 in Q1, while revenue per quarter stayed in a fairly tight band around US$3.9b to US$4.6b. This fits with the idea that margins and mix, not just top line, are doing a lot of the work.
  • At the same time, the consensus narrative highlights ongoing integration of acquisitions like the Fikes and CEFCO stores. The data supports this through solid trailing EPS and net income despite quarterly ups and downs, suggesting investors will be watching how those stores contribute across the next few reporting periods.

Next Steps

To see how these results tie into long-term growth, risks, and valuation, check out the full range of community narratives for Casey's General Stores on Simply Wall St. Add the company to your watchlist or portfolio so you'll be alerted when the story evolves.

Given the mix of confidence and caution around Casey's General Stores, this is a moment to move quickly, review the full data, and weigh both sides by checking the 2 key rewards and 1 important warning sign.

See What Else Is Out There Beyond Casey's General Stores

Casey's General Stores carries a premium 41.5x P/E and trades above its DCF fair value, so valuation expectations leave little room for disappointment.

If that rich pricing makes you uneasy, this is a good moment to scan for stocks where expectations and price look more aligned using the 44 high quality undervalued stocks.

This article by Simply Wall St is general in nature. We provide commentary based on historical data and analyst forecasts only using an unbiased methodology and our articles are not intended to be financial advice. It does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and does not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. We aim to bring you long-term focused analysis driven by fundamental data. Note that our analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material. Simply Wall St has no position in any stocks mentioned.