Hilltop Holdings (HTH) opened 2026 with Q1 revenue of about US$298.7 million and basic EPS of roughly US$0.64, alongside trailing 12 month revenue of about US$1.26 billion and EPS of around US$2.63 that were 26.4% higher year over year. Over recent quarters the company has seen revenue move from roughly US$306.9 million in Q4 2024 to about US$322.1 million in Q4 2025, while quarterly EPS shifted from around US$0.55 to about US$0.69 over the same span, giving investors a fuller sense of how the latest headline numbers fit within the broader trend. With net profit margins running at 12.8% over the last year and sector specific metrics like net interest margin and non performing loans in focus, the story now turns to how durable these margins look from here.

See our full analysis for Hilltop Holdings.

With the quarterly scorecard on the table, the next step is to see how these results line up with the big narratives around Hilltop's growth, risks, and profitability that many investors follow.

12.8% Net Margin Backed by 3.15% Net Interest Margin

• Hilltop reported a 12.8% net profit margin over the last 12 months, supported by a Q1 2026 net interest margin of 3.15% and trailing net interest margin of 3% that sit above the 2.83% level seen in the earlier trailing data.
• Consensus narrative highlights loan demand in Texas and across the Sun Belt and points to operating efficiency gains, and the margin data partly lines up with that story while also showing where execution still matters:
  • Net interest margin moved from 2.83% in the older trailing figures to 3% on the latest trailing data and 3.15% in Q1 2026, which supports the idea that pricing and mix are helping earnings, especially as non performing loans are at US$61.0 million versus US$88.1 million in the earlier quarterly data.
  • At the same time, the trailing cost to income ratio of 53.16% compares with quarterly ratios that have ranged between about 51% and 55%, so efficiency is not on a one way path and investors still need to watch whether digital initiatives translate into further cost discipline.

Bulls often point to expanding margins and improving asset quality as the backbone of their story, and these figures show exactly where that argument is strongest and where it still needs proof 🐂 Hilltop Holdings Bull Case

Non Performing Loans Down To US$61 Million

• Non performing loans now sit at US$61.0 million in Q1 2026, compared with US$88.1 million in the earlier quarterly snapshot and a trailing 12 month figure that also stands at US$61.0 million, pointing to a smaller pool of problem credits than in the past data provided.
• Bears worry that concentration in Texas and mortgage origination could pressure credit quality, and the current non performing loan figures give a more mixed picture for that cautious view:
  • The dataset shows non performing loans stepping down from US$88.1 million across the earlier quarterly data points to US$81.5 million, then US$72.7 million, US$68.3 million, US$53.4 million and finally US$61.0 million, so recent levels are well below the starting point even though the very latest quarter is slightly above Q4 2025.
  • Because total loans data is last listed at US$8.3b in Q4 2025, investors following the bearish narrative can see that current problem loans are a small fraction of that book in absolute terms, while still keeping an eye on any future tick up that might come from housing or regional stress.

Skeptics focus on concentration risk and housing exposure, and this credit quality trend shows why they watch the loan book so closely 🐻 Hilltop Holdings Bear Case

DCF Fair Value Of US$21.91 Versus US$36.65 Price

• The shares trade around US$36.65 with a P/E of 13.3x, while a DCF fair value in the dataset is US$21.91 and the consensus analyst price target is US$39.00, implying a small gap between current price and that target compared with the larger gap to the DCF output.
• Consensus narrative expects modest revenue growth of about 1.3% per year and earnings of US$112.5 million by around 2029, and the current valuation metrics sit against those expectations in a way that gives investors a clear checklist:
  • Trailing 12 month earnings of US$161.3 million and EPS of US$2.63 are higher than the US$112.5 million earnings and US$2.15 EPS analysts project, while the price target of US$39.00 implies a 20.9x P/E on those future earnings compared with the current 13.3x and a US Banks industry P/E reference of 11.9x in the forecast set.
  • Because trailing earnings grew 26.4% year over year while the same dataset shows a 29.9% per year decline over five years and an expected 12.4% annual earnings decline ahead, readers can see why some models such as the DCF fair value of US$21.91 mark the shares more cautiously than the current P/E and price target suggest.

Next Steps

To see how these results tie into long-term growth, risks, and valuation, check out the full range of community narratives for Hilltop Holdings on Simply Wall St. Add the company to your watchlist or portfolio so you'll be alerted when the story evolves.

Seeing both risks and rewards in the story so far is a good starting point. The real edge comes from testing the data yourself and moving quickly to shape your own view, then weighing up the 2 key rewards and 2 important warning signs.

See What Else Is Out There

Hilltop's earnings story includes a DCF fair value of US$21.91 against a US$36.65 price and analyst expectations for earnings to trend below current trailing levels.

If that mix of valuation tension and earnings caution makes you uneasy, use the 56 high quality undervalued stocks to quickly focus on companies where price and fundamentals line up more tightly.

This article by Simply Wall St is general in nature. We provide commentary based on historical data and analyst forecasts only using an unbiased methodology and our articles are not intended to be financial advice. It does not constitute a recommendation to buy or sell any stock, and does not take account of your objectives, or your financial situation. We aim to bring you long-term focused analysis driven by fundamental data. Note that our analysis may not factor in the latest price-sensitive company announcements or qualitative material. Simply Wall St has no position in any stocks mentioned.