Kirkland & Ellis trial win, $17 million fee award wiped out in computer chip trade secrets appeal
Ultra FTSE China 25 Proshares XPP | 0.00 |
By Mike Scarcella
WASHINGTON, July 14 (Reuters) - A U.S. federal appeals court on Tuesday overturned a $40 million jury verdict for technology company Comet Technologies and an award of more than $17 million in legal fees in a lawsuit accusing chip industry rival XP Power of stealing trade secrets.
Here are the details:
A three-judge panel of the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered a new trial in the trade secrets lawsuit that Comet filed in 2020 against XP. The companies manufacture components used in making computer chips.
Comet, represented by law firm Kirkland & Ellis, prevailed at trial in 2020 on some of its claims that XP stole trade secrets when three employees joined the company from Comet. XP, represented by Latham & Watkins, has denied any wrongdoing. The $40 million verdict included $20 million in punitive damages.
The appeals court, in a divided 2-1 order, said the federal judge who presided over the trial wrongly informed the jury that XP had a burden to disprove a key part of Comet’s allegations. “XP did not invite the error, and Comet has not convinced us that the error was harmless,” Circuit Judge David Hamilton wrote.
In a dissent, Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay said the trial court’s instruction was incorrect but the jury was likely to reach the same verdict even if it had been instructed properly.
After the trial, Kirkland sought and was awarded compensation for the work of 18 attorneys who said they spent more than 15,400 hours on the case for Comet.
Lawyers for Comet and XP did not immediately respond to requests for comment about the appeals court order.
