In December 2023, W.P. Carey (NYSE:WPC) did something it hadn’t done in decades: it cut its dividend. The payout dropped from $1.071 to $0.860 per share—a 19.7% reduction that sent income investors running. But here’s what happened next.

Eight consecutive quarters of dividend increases. The payout now stands at $0.920, announced December 15, 2025. That’s a 7% climb from the post-cut low. The recovery is real—but the gap to the old dividend remains.

At current levels, WPC’s quarterly payout is still about 14% below where it was before the cut. For investors who bought for the old yield, that difference matters. For new buyers evaluating the stock today, the question is different: is the structure behind this dividend stable enough to keep climbing?

The Numbers Behind the Recovery

Three metrics frame WPC’s current position as of Q3 2025.

1. AFFO: $1.25 per share (Q3 2025)

Adjusted funds from operations rose 5.9% year-over-year. This is the cash flow that supports the dividend. For the nine months ended September 30, 2025, the payout ratio sits at 73.0%—leaving room for continued modest increases without stretching the balance sheet.

Source: W.P. Carey Q3 2025 Supplemental, Filed October 28, 2025

2. Net Debt-to-EBITDA: 5.8x (inclusive of unsettled forward equity)

Leverage remains within management’s target range of mid-to-high 5s. This isn’t low by REIT standards, but it’s stable. The company ended Q3 with $2.14 billion in liquidity, including available credit facility capacity and unsettled forward equity.

Source: W.P. Carey Q3 2025 Supplemental

3. Investment-Grade Ratings Intact

WPC maintains investment-grade credit ratings and, as of late 2025, remains roughly two notches above the BBB- cliff—the threshold below which institutional selling pressure typically accelerates.

Source: W.P. Carey Investor Relations

What Actually Changed Since the Cut

The 2023 dividend reduction wasn’t random. WPC exited its office portfolio entirely, spinning off those assets and refocusing on industrial, warehouse, and retail net lease properties. The company also began selling its self-storage operating properties—a process that continued through 2025.

For full-year 2025 (announced January 7, 2026), WPC completed $1.5 billion in dispositions, including $785 million from self-storage sales. The proceeds helped fund a record $2.1 billion in new investments at an average initial cap rate of 7.6%.

The result: a more concentrated portfolio, but one that management argues is higher quality and more predictable.

Occupancy dipped to 97.0% at quarter-end, down from 98.2% in Q2 2025. Management attributed this to known move-outs—including Tesco, True Value, and several Hellweg stores—and called the decline temporary.

What Would Change the Trajectory

Three triggers could slow or reverse the dividend recovery:

• Occupancy below 95%: Further tenant losses without backfill would pressure cash flow. The Hellweg exposure, in particular, remains a watch item—though it has already been reduced materially, from the 6th to the 17th largest tenant by ABR at year-end.
• Leverage above 6.5x: If net debt-to-EBITDA rises materially above the current 5.8x, dividend growth could stall as cash gets redirected to debt service.
• Rating downgrade: A move to BBB or below would raise borrowing costs and signal deteriorating credit quality. No such action is currently anticipated, but it remains the structural risk that income investors should monitor.

What I’d Watch

WPC’s dividend recovery is real, but incomplete.

The 73% YTD payout ratio and 5.8x leverage suggest the structure can support continued small increases. The 12.1-year weighted average lease term provides visibility.

But the gap to the old dividend is a reminder: cuts leave scars. For investors who held through December 2023, full recovery hasn’t arrived. For those evaluating WPC today, the question isn’t whether the dividend will return to $1.07—it’s whether the current $0.92, backed by improving fundamentals, offers enough margin of safety at this price.

Eight straight hikes is a pattern. Whether it continues depends on occupancy, leverage, and the next earnings cycle.

---

Disclosure: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author holds no position in WPC.

---

Sources:

• W.P. Carey Q3 2025 Supplemental (Filed October 28, 2025)
• W.P. Carey Full-Year 2025 Business Update (January 7, 2026)
• W.P. Carey Dividend Announcement (December 15, 2025)

Benzinga Disclaimer: This article is from an unpaid external contributor. It does not represent Benzinga’s reporting and has not been edited for content or accuracy.